“This Time It’s Different… Or Not?” Stock Talk Update, Friday April 17, 2026
Investors, If you’ve watched markets over the years, you’ve heard this phrase again and again: “This time is different.”
Today, the headlines might feel heavier than the past—war, oil spikes, political uncertainty, and AI disruption. It may feel different. That said, investing on one’s feelings and emotions is usually a recipe for bad outcomes.
But investors is it actually different… or does it just feel that way? Are you possibly letting your emotions drive your decisions?
Let’s walk through the data.
Section 1: Core Message
- Markets price uncertainty quickly, albeit not perfectly—but efficiently over time
- War headlines feel extreme, but markets most often adjust faster than expected
- Short-term volatility is normal; long-term returns follow earnings, innovation, and interest rates.
- Every stock market correction has a new reason—but the pattern more often than not repeats
Section 2: War and Markets
What History Actually Shows
Let’s go back and look at major conflicts, wars, and how stocks performed in the first year.
World War II (1942)
- Market initially declined sharply in early 1942
- But once the USA’s direction became clearer, stocks bottomed and rallied strongly
- Full-year return in 1942: positive to the tune of 19.75% to almost 36.5%, each and every year the US was active in WW2, 1942-45.
Korean War (1950)
- Surprise invasion triggered volatility
- Market recovered quickly as economic activity accelerated
- Full-year return: 30.81%
Vietnam War Escalation (1965)
- Gradual buildup, not a onetime shock event
- However, Strong economic backdrop supported equities
- Full-year return: 12.4%
Iraq War (2003)
- Markets declined leading into the war
- Once conflict began, uncertainty dropped, it didn’t rise and stocks rallied sharply
- Full-year return: ~+28.36%
Investors, historically, more often than not, markets bottom near the start of conflict or soon after the fighting starts and then begin to recover on peak uncertainty, as uncertainty declines even if the fighting continues.
Section 3: Why Today Feels Different
Today’s concerns include geopolitical conflict, oil volatility, AI disruption, and higher interest rates.
It also feels different because now, advances in technology have given us up to date information at our fingertips almost immediately. You don’t have to wait for the newspaper, or the nightly news updates. Heck real-time ship traffic and troop movements are available almost immediately on your phone from posters on X or Substack.
However, investors the U.S. economy remains resilient, earnings are growing and accelerating, and innovation continues.
Section 4: Reality of Corrections
Since 2009, as in most years, >5% corrections are frequent, with a median decline of ~7.6%.
Each correction has a unique narrative, but the pattern is consistent: markets correct, and more often than not, recover, and advance. Here’s a great table from Charlie Biello of all the >5% S&P 500 corrections since the end of the GFC in 2009. Included is the reason or rational many investors gave for not investing in those years.
Section 5: Investor Takeaways
- Expect volatility—it is normal. It’s the risk you get from investing in stocks with the reward being, trying to grow your money at a multiple of inflation.
- Try to Avoid reacting emotionally to headlines alone
- Do what you can to Focus on long-term fundamentals in growth industries if that’s your style or focus on consistency and durability of dividend growth if you are a dividend growth investor.
- And investors, do what you can Recognize opportunities in fear-driven selloffs. Maybe get on the phone and talk to your advisor about investing more during highly volatile times, vs. pulling back are raising cash in a down market.
Closing
So, investors the next time you hear “this time is different,” pause, look at the data—and remember, in most years, it usually isn’t, due to the strength and stability of the USA economy and companies that make up the earnings of the S&P500. Whether your priority is growth, income, or a combination of both, the Oak Harvest team is here to help you plan for your family’s financial future — no matter where you are in your career or retirement journey.
Do you need a retirement plan that goes beyond allocating funds to truly fit your needs? We can help you create a retirement life plan customized for your retirement vision and legacy. Call us at 877-896-0040 or fill out this form for a free visit: https://click2retire.com/lets-connect
Chris Perras
CFA®, CLU®, ChFC®
Chief Investment Officer, Financial Advisor
Chris is a seasoned investment professional with over 25 years of experience working with some of the most successful money management firms in the world. Chris has made it a point in his career to adapt as the market landscape changes, seeking to utilize the appropriate investment strategy for a given market environment. His transition from managing billions of dollars at the institutional level to helping individuals and families retire is guided by a desire to see first-hand the impact he is making in the lives of clients at Oak Harvest.